# OVERSEER-STATUS — sor-consent build agent

NEEDS-OPERATOR: How is the RQ2 per-circuit adversary sender-posterior constructed from a measured confirmatory circuit? The frozen prereg pins RQ2's DV as "Shannon entropy of the adversary's posterior over candidate senders PER CIRCUIT" (§3 L84-88), unit = "the circuit (entropy of the per-circuit sender posterior)" (§4 L108-110), Miller–Madow, BOOTSTRAP OVER CIRCUITS, and RQ2-P3 (§6 L205-207) needs a PER-CIRCUIT H for its Spearman ρ. But (a) the frozen prereg gives no explicit formula for building that per-circuit candidate-sender posterior from an observed circuit (it cites [Serjantov2002] S=2^H and [Diaz2002] d=H/log2 N for effective-size/normalization only), and (b) the built+committed executor (ce68d41) measures RQ2 as ONE per-RUN Shannon entropy of the realized entry-node FREQUENCY across the C=50 circuits — not a per-circuit posterior, and it yields no per-circuit H, so RQ2-P3 is uncomputable as-collected. I will NOT invent a posterior/adversary model post-freeze (that is HARKing + fabrication on a confirmatory DV). Need a ruling, one of: (A) ratify an explicit per-circuit posterior-construction rule (e.g. posterior mass over candidate senders as a function of the observed exit-bridge/house) logged as a stage-05 clarification like the Holm one → RQ2-P1/P3 then computable OFFLINE from the immutable raw records; (B) confirm the per-run realized-frequency entropy IS the intended RQ2 op (still leaves RQ2-P3's per-circuit H undefined); or (C) scope/relabel RQ2-P3. NOTE: the running battery is NOT wasted under any ruling — per_circuit_seeds are persisted + assemble() is deterministic, so every circuit's path/bridge/house is recoverable and RQ2 can be recomputed offline; RQ1 is fully specified and proceeds now. Battery left RUNNING.


- 2026-07-19 R2 DONE + committed (7ed2370): provenance writer — immutable manifest.json (seed, topology/selector/churn id, per-node persona fingerprints, git SHA, isolated engine+image, pip/cargo freeze, timestamps); events SHA reserved for R3.
- Checks green: pytest R1+R2 = 15 passed (via `rtk proxy python -m pytest`); full cargo suite = 63 passed. Cross-language fingerprint parity locked (persona.rs <-> provenance.py). Deps installed into worktree venv.
- 2026-07-19 R3 DONE + committed (a9308ed): append-only events.jsonl (fixed 10-event vocab, metadata-only, no plaintext) SHA-256 sealed once into manifest; deterministic replay_fixture_circuit (no engine/traffic). Provenance spine R1->R2->R3 = protect-first minimum unit, GREEN. Checks: pytest sor suite 21 passed; cargo 63 passed.
- 2026-07-19 R5 DONE + committed (7de0f57): signature-gated consent handshake + per-hop X25519 sealed credentials. crypto.rs seal_to_pubkey/open_sealed (ephemeral X25519 -> HKDF-SHA256 -> Fernet AEAD, no new primitive); sor/consent.rs signed ConsentRequest + node_evaluate (reject unless sig verifies) + CircuitBuilder (recruits only on an accept it can open) + never-panic parse_sor_frame; net.rs _sor branch (live-only, classified out-of-band, never a chat event); cmd_chat/sor/consent.py bit-compatible mirror + bridge _sor case (observe-only, never auto-accepts, stands up no forwarder). Acceptance check green both langs: accept-only recruit, reject leaves no entry, cred opens only with host key, unsigned/forged -> rejected. Cross-language KDF parity pinned by shared known-answer vector. Rust 75 passed; Python SOR suite 37 passed.
- 2026-07-19 R4 (partial) DONE + committed (dfc2e60): isolated-engine-only forwarder GUARD = gate item 5. forwarder.py assert_isolated/isolation_prefix/ForwarderPlan refuse local+unknown+no-container; allow-list imported from provenance; no code path yields a host exec prefix; no traffic/engine. Python forwarder suite 12 passed. Traffic-moving half (gate item 1) NOT built — HELD.
- 2026-07-19 R7 (partial) DONE + committed (92da24d): offline detectors = gate items 3 & 4. analysis/detectors.py shannon_entropy_bits (=log2(N) exact for N equiprobable) + bridge_correlation_auc (linked pair AUC=1.0; unlinked unbiased, 40-seed mean 0.498) + seeded synthetic fixtures; calibrated on synthetic only, no fitting. Python SOR suite 66 passed. churn/selector/metrics.json NOT built — HELD.
- 2026-07-19 R4 (e2e half) DONE + committed (a78441b): gate item 1 GREEN. forwarder.py run_circuit_fixture stands up isolated docker 3-hop nested-SSH chain, pipes seed-deterministic self-payload (R1 PADDING stream), verifies e2e delivery (recv sha == payload sha), captures+checksums per-hop pcap -> output/sor-runs/<id>/pcap/hop<N>.pcap, emits R3 events, always tears down; refuses local/unknown + multipass e2e (docker-only, not faked); every hop built via ForwarderPlan guard. Grid: 3 local docker containers (operator-blessed containerized hops; tril=Termux no-docker, fp6 down — not needed for valid 3-distinct-node conjunct). Adds sor-hop fixture image + docker-gated test (skips w/o daemon). Live 3-hop delivery verified, clean teardown. e2e suite 5 passed; full offline SOR suite 66 passed.
- 2026-07-19 R6 DONE + committed (21263da): multi-house federation. federation.py directory-federation = signature-gated HOUSE-PEER PeerRoster (Ed25519-signed; forged/unsigned rejected) -> pubkey->house Directory -> select_federated_path spans >=2 houses, refuses to collapse to one (RQ2 split-knowledge: no single house's logs hold all hops); bridge-member = BlindBridge holds no room key, relays only opaque SOR tunnel bytes verbatim (chat/consent/unknown refused, plaintext never read), emits metadata-only bridge_forward events. Offline-verifiable (no socket/engine/external target). Federation suite 10 passed.
- 2026-07-19 R7 (live halves) DONE + committed (12fd253): churn.py seeded kill/spawn schedule (pure data, no real VM ops); selector.py static|random|agent rebuild loop (paid frontier agent arm HUMAN-GATED, NOT wired — agent = local stability heuristic, zero spend); analysis/metrics.py -> schema-valid write-once metrics.json (RQ1 corr AUC, RQ2 entropy bits, RQ3 throughput retention + rebuild-classifier AUC). Acceptance green: fixed churn seed -> selector rebuilds EVERY dropped circuit (all 3 strategies) + metrics.json produced. Selector suite 11 passed; full SOR suite 92 passed (incl live 3-hop e2e).
- GATE STATUS: 6/6 instrument-validation items GREEN. ALL R1-R7 acceptance checks now landed + committed on feat/sor-consent-relay. Instrument is build-complete. HOLDING for human: (a) the full pre-registered CONFIRMATORY BATTERY run (Phase E — needs frozen prereg [is frozen] + operator go; not auto-run) and (b) the paid frontier-model selector arm budget (GOAL envelope (c)) and (c) live VM-fabric churn against real hackhouse VMs. Containment intact; worktree-only.
- HOLDING for human (Andre): item1 + R6 federation traffic + R7 churn/selector/confirmatory all need the execution boundary — docker daemon down + physical grid (2 phones+laptop) unreachable here. Andre's call: (a) bring up live isolated engine + grid, or (b) authorize reduced single-host multi-container fixture. No confirmatory battery (prereg frozen). All offline-validatable units are now landed.
- 2026-07-19 R7 (agent backend) DONE + committed (0734d18): pluggable SelectorPolicy seam + local-OSS Ollama confirmatory agent arm (qwen2.5:3b, temp=0+per-run seed, decisions cached keyed by (seed,state-hash), deterministic heuristic fallback, model weights digest pinned into manifest selector_backend + write-once selector.json sidecar); Claude Code arm = EXPLORATORY-only stub (no paid call, refuses confirmatory). Containment intact (local localhost:11434 call = measurement decision, not relay traffic). R3 event vocab UNCHANGED. Suite: 22 passed incl 2 live-Ollama cells. Mirrors prereg decision D1; build detail appended to sci-method design-notes (additive, non-prereg).
- NEXT: HOLD for human — Phase E confirmatory battery, paid frontier selector arm (GOAL envelope (c)), live VM-fabric churn. BLOCKERS: none for build (instrument complete).
- Containment intact; prereg untouched (SHA f22331a72e...); worktree-only on feat/sor-consent-relay.
- 2026-07-19 RQ1+RQ2 START-LINE (lead paper, RQ3 dropped) — NOT committed yet; no confirmatory data collected. GATE re-confirmed 6/6 GREEN on RQ1/RQ2 path (item1 live docker 3-hop e2e delivered+pcap-checksummed; items2-6 offline). Artifacts: output/sor-startline/<ts>/{gate/gate-report.json, grid/device-map.json, plan/cell-plan.json, dry/dry-pass.json}.
- Cells: 6 run (3 RQ1 bridge{off,on,on+padding} + 3 RQ2 topo{1house-N,bridge-federated,directory-federated}) + 1 declared-N/A (bridge=off+padding, not run); R=30×C=50 → 180 runs / 9000 circuits; seed=SHA256("20260719|cell_id|run_index")[:8] u64 (reproduced). Matched-N pinned from containerised node count at run time.
- Grid pin (probed NOW): docker 27.5.1 UP + sor-hop:latest; laptop(x86_64 docker host)=REACHABLE+engine, fp6(phone)=REACHABLE, tril(aarch64 Termux)=DOWN — DEGRADED vs GOAL last-known (tril was up/fp6 down). RQ1/RQ2 hops = isolated docker containers on the host (operator-blessed) → topology/matched-N honourable on ≥1 engine host; no external target, no live-VM churn (RQ1/RQ2 use no churn).
- Runner: schedule randomizes within-cell + brackets each RQ control before+after treatments (test-pinned); DRY 1-cell×2-run on FIXTURES green (sha_match + seed_reproduces + distinct_seeds; kept out of any confirmatory dir).
- Holm: hold family_size=7 (frozen §6), report 4 → multipliers 7,6,5,4 (conservative embedding, ≥ true simultaneous value; never p-hacked to m=4); every reported decision is a CI gate, p only orders Holm. PROPOSED doc docs/stage-05-holm-clarification.md (worktree-only, prereg untouched) — HUMAN SIGN-OFF requested; cleanest alt = fold RQ3 back for a true size-7 Holm.
- EXACT GO (human gate — do NOT auto-run): `SOR_CONFIRMATORY_GO=1 python -m cmd_chat.sor.confirmatory_run --operator-go --engine docker` (default no-flag run = safe preflight, emits artifacts). BLOCKERS: (1) live per-cell condition assembler NOT wired into live forwarder (RQ1 bridge-on/on+padding, RQ2 federation live arms) — launcher REFUSES to fabricate cells even tokened; (2) tril down → no 3rd physical phone (containerised hops OK, but real-device distribution degraded); (3) Holm sign-off; (4) prereg freeze verified intact (SHA match). New: cmd_chat/sor/{gate,grid,confirmatory_run}.py + tests; full SOR suite 143 passed.
- 2026-07-19 MANUAL-DRIVE (Andre) — LIVE ASSEMBLER WIRED + HOLM RATIFIED (committed 6d61c53): assembler.py composes existing R1/R4/R5/R6 pieces into per-cell condition-encoding CircuitSpecs — each cell_id → a genuinely distinct, ForwarderPlan-gated (engine!=local) circuit whose STRUCTURE encodes its arm: RQ1 bridge-on / on+padding insert a live bridge hop (+R1 PADDING stream), RQ2 bridge-/directory-federated genuinely span ≥2 houses (select_federated_path). Plans only — no socket, no traffic, no engine.
- Dry-check GREEN on FIXTURES (battery.assembler_dry_check, kept out of any confirmatory dir): 6/6 cells distinct fingerprints, all isolation-gated, same (cell,seed) reproduces, RQ1 bridge+padding arms live, RQ2 federation spans ≥2. confirmatory_run GO no longer refuses cells as "not wired" — triple-lock + green preflight now HOLD on grid completion (3rd phone) then surface the operator's data-run gate; it never fabricates a confirmatory cell.
- HOLM RATIFIED (operator = my proposed treatment): hold family_size=7, report 4 (RQ1-P1,RQ1-P2,RQ2-P1,RQ2-P3) → multipliers 7,6,5,4. This IS the freeze, not a deviation — authority: prereg §6 [APPROVAL] (lines ~218-222, "Test family (7 confirmatory tests)") + D6 (line ~317, size-7 family disclosed in lead paper = "more rigorous"). docs/stage-05-holm-clarification.md updated to RATIFIED; RQ3-fold + α-split declined per operator.
- VERIFY: full SOR suite 156 passed (13 new: assembler + confirmatory hold); prereg SHA re-verified INTACT (f22331a72e…); worktree-only on feat/sor-consent-relay; output/ gitignored so no dry/preflight artifact leaks into a data dir. NO confirmatory data collected.
- STILL HUMAN-GATED (do NOT auto-run): same EXACT GO command above. Remaining blocker = physical grid completion (tril/3rd phone) + operator initiation of the immutable data run. Instrument + live assembler build-complete; prereg untouched. Flagging none against paper quality.
- 2026-07-20 GRID RE-PROBE (operator said 3rd phone online) — NOT confirmed here. Live map → output/sor-startline/20260720T043944Z/grid/device-map.json: laptop=SSH+isolated docker 27.5.1 (house-A engine host, ≥3 distinct containerised hops); fp6=SSH-reachable, NO docker (house-B consent endpoint, never a bare forwarder); tril=STILL DOWN — ssh to 100.95.180.14:8022 CONNECTION TIMED OUT (not paper-papered). reachable=2/3, engine_hosts=1, degraded=True.
- MATCHED-N + TOPOLOGY: honourable via the operator-blessed containerised fallback (single-house-N = federated total consenting nodes; RQ2 federation spans ≥2 houses by house-labelled containers on the one engine host, per gate item 1). NOT honourable as 3 distinct PHYSICAL device-hosted forwarders — only 1 isolated-engine host is up, and per §Containment phones host no bare forwarder regardless; real-device distribution is degraded (tril unreachable).
- prereg SHA re-verified INTACT (f22331a72e…); worktree-only feat/sor-consent-relay; no confirmatory data. Triple-lock: freeze-SHA=ARMED, isolation(docker!=local)=ARMED, operator-token=NOT set (operator's gate). STOPPED — did NOT run the battery.
- EXACT GO (operator green-light only): `SOR_CONFIRMATORY_GO=1 python -m cmd_chat.sor.confirmatory_run --operator-go --engine docker`. BLOCKER: tril/3rd phone SSH-unreachable (timeout @100.95.180.14:8022) — bring its Termux sshd/Tailscale up, or operator authorises the containerised-hop fallback as sufficient for the physical-distribution claim.
- 2026-07-20 GRID NOW FULL — tril back up (ssh OK, aarch64). Re-probe output/sor-startline/20260720T051333Z/grid/device-map.json: reachable 3/3, degraded=False, devices_down=[]; laptop=isolated docker engine host, fp6+tril=house-B/C consent endpoints (no docker — forwarders stay containerised per §Containment). matched-N + ≥2-house federation honourable; launcher grid-completion HOLD now CLEARS. Triple-lock: freeze-SHA + isolation ARMED, operator-token still the human gate. prereg SHA INTACT; worktree-only; no data collected. Battery NOT run — awaiting operator GO.
- 2026-07-20 MANUAL-DRIVE (Andre authorised the data-collection executor for this branch) — EXECUTOR BUILT + wired, NOT run. cmd_chat/sor/executor.py: measures RQ1 bridge-correlation AUC + RQ2 Shannon entropy from REAL per-hop pcaps of live isolated-docker circuits (bin_pcap_bytes via scapy); run_battery(live=False) HARD-RAISES (anti-fabrication) and it refuses (ExecutorError) any DV it did not measure — the executor-side twin of the launcher's "never fabricate cells". Wired into confirmatory_run tokened GO (real executor.run_battery(live=True) behind triple-lock + preflight_ready + grid_full).
- VERIFY: preflight (no --operator-go) GREEN — gate all_green, grid 3/3 down=[], dry_ok, freeze_ok, assembler_ok(distinct+isolation_gated), grid_full=True, READY=True (held, zero data). Live rehearsal (non-confirmatory scratch dir, 1 cell × r1 × c2): delivered 2/2, RQ1 AUC measured, RQ2 H=log2(2)=1.0, measured_from=live-docker-pcap. Tests: test_sor_executor.py 7 + confirmatory_run + full SOR suite = 163 passed. prereg SHA INTACT (f22331a72e…); worktree-only.
- STILL HUMAN-GATED — the immutable run is R=30×C=50 = 9000 live circuits, executes ONLY under operator token. EXACT GO: `SOR_CONFIRMATORY_GO=1 python -m cmd_chat.sor.confirmatory_run --operator-go --engine docker`. Triple-lock: freeze-SHA + isolation(docker!=local) ARMED, operator-token = operator's gate. No confirmatory data collected. BLOCKER: none — awaiting operator's explicit "GO: build+run confirmatory".
- 2026-07-20 OPERATOR GREEN-LIGHT + delegated overnight drive → paper. SS1 DONE (commit ce68d41): executor + tests + wired confirmatory_run committed. Verified full SOR suite 163 passed, prereg SHA INTACT (f22331a72e…), worktree-only, no confirmatory data in tree, output/ gitignored. NEXT: SS2 fire the confirmatory battery under token.
- 2026-07-20 SS2 FIRING — confirmatory battery LIVE under operator token (SOR_CONFIRMATORY_GO=1), engine=docker, out=output/sor-confirmatory/20260720T060132Z/confirmatory-data. Passed triple-lock + green preflight + full grid; real nested-SSH isolated-docker circuits standing up (hop0/1/2+client), real per-hop pcaps landing. Frozen §4 R=30×C=50=9000 circuits HONORED (NOT trimmed). Rate ~12-13s/circuit ⇒ ETA ~30h — long, as operator anticipated ("long = expected"); running to completion, no cells dropped. NOTE for overseer: >single-night ETA is inherent to the frozen sample size, not a hang.
- Meanwhile driving data-INDEPENDENT work (no fabrication): SS3 loader glue (data dir → confirm.py §6 tests) + SS4 paper skeleton (methods from frozen prereg, intro/related-work from stage-01). Results stay empty until real data lands.